COLLAGEN
What is Collagen and what is the Difference between Bovine and Marine Collagen?
Fish: Friend or Foe?
Collagen provides structure and support to our skin, muscles, bones, and connective tissues. However, collagen levels begin to decrease around the age of 30. Fortunately, we can support our collagen levels through dietary sources and supplements, which may help maintain joint health, skin appearance, and hair and nail strength. Collagen supplements may also play a role in supporting fitness goals by aiding mobility and muscle maintenance, potentially benefiting overall weight management strategies as well.
Bovine vs. Marine Collagen
At WillPowders, we’re often asked about the difference between bovine and marine collagen. Our collagen is derived from bovine sources—a choice we made with careful consideration and research. While some articles suggest that marine collagen may be superior, research does not universally support these claims. Here’s why we stand by our decision to use bovine collagen:
- Composition and Functionality: Marine collagen is composed of Type 1 collagen, which primarily supports skin, hair, and bone health. Bovine collagen, on the other hand, includes both Type 1 and Type 3 collagen, which may support not only skin, hair, and bones but also muscles, arteries, and organs—vital elements for overall health and longevity. Research shows that bovine collagen’s composition may offer broader benefits than marine collagen.
- Sustainability and Ethical Sourcing: We prioritise sustainability at WillPowders. Research into marine collagen production highlights concerns with overfishing and unsustainable practices, as some marine collagen products use shark skin. In contrast, our bovine collagen is sourced from Swiss farms that ensure high standards of animal welfare. These farms guarantee no growth hormones and zero exposure to glyphosate. This approach allows us to provide a traceable, responsibly-sourced product.
Collagen Sustainability
Bovine collagen offers a sustainable choice, as it is derived from cowhides, which are also used in industries like leather production, making it a more environmentally efficient choice. In contrast, marine collagen production often requires fish scales, which are not commonly used in other industries, potentially leading to resource inefficiencies.
Collagen Quality and Gut Health
Our bovine collagen is a 100% pure, Swiss grass-fed hydrolysed collagen peptide powder. Unlike marine collagen, which can have a strong fishy taste that often requires flavouring additives, our bovine collagen is clean and unflavoured. Additives in marine collagen may impact gut health, potentially leading to symptoms like bloating and digestive discomfort. Research on marine collagen primarily focuses on cosmetic benefits such as increasing skin moisture and reducing fine wrinkles, while studies indicate that collagen from warm-blooded mammals may be more effective in supporting collagen levels than collagen from marine sources.
Marine Collagen: Points to Consider
If you’re considering marine collagen, here are a few things to bear in mind:
- Sourcing: Ask your supplement provider about the source of the fish (the specific ocean, and whether it’s line-caught) and inquire if it is certified “Shark Free.”
- Contaminants: Marine sources may have exposure to contaminants. You may want to check if products are third-party tested for substances like BMAA, which is typically not tested in sea-derived supplements.
Conclusion: Why Bovine Collagen?
At WillPowders, we recommend our bovine collagen as a sustainable, ethically sourced, and highly versatile supplement. While both marine and bovine collagen offer beneficial amino acids, bovine collagen may offer a broader range of support, potentially benefiting everything from skin and bone health to muscle and organ function. Marine collagen, though similar in structure, may be less suited for sustainable production and may contain additives that could impact gut health.
If you choose marine collagen, be sure to research its sourcing, sustainability practices, and possible effects on gut health. For a versatile collagen that aligns with sustainability and provides a complete amino acid profile, we’re proud to offer our grass-fed Swiss bovine collagen as an ideal choice.
Disclaimer
Our blogs are written with love in the hope that they go some way in helping you feel like the rockstar you are, and whilst we do our due diligence, research like maniacs and fact check our stuff, we know everyone’s journey is different. They are intended to educate and empower you, not usurp medical advice. We would never advise you to stop, adjust, or modify any prescription medication without the direct supervision of your healthcare practitioner, but don’t be afraid to talk to your doctor about your new found knowledge, brought to you by the marvels of nature because they don't know everything! Blogs are always informed by Davinia but often written by a member of the team. Not all blogs reflect Davinia's experiences and sometimes provide alternative perspectives